WhatsApp Skip to main content

Dr. Harsh J Shah

Laser vs surgery for piles: what each really does

Last updated: 18-Oct-2026

Tapping Book on WhatsApp will likely open the WhatsApp app on your phone.

Dr Harsh Shah, GI and proctology surgeon, Ahmedabad

Dr Harsh Shah
MS, MCh (Surgical Gastroenterology), DrNB (Surgical Gastroenterology)
Registered with Gujarat Medical Council, Reg. No. G-38738
GI & Proctology Surgeon
Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital, Vasna, Ahmedabad · 18 years of experience · +91 63555 64601
★★★★★ Google rating: 4.94 from 18 reviews

In short

Laser shrinks a pile from inside through a pinhole. Surgery cuts the pile away. Banding ties it off in the OPD.

Laser usually hurts less at first, and people return to work sooner. But piles come back more often after laser.

Dr Harsh Shah uses banding and open surgery, not laser. Your grade of piles and any outside lump decide.

What laser treatment for piles actually does

In laser treatment, a thin fibre goes into the pile through a tiny hole in the skin and heats it from the inside.

The full name is laser haemorrhoidoplasty. It is done under spinal or general anaesthesia, usually as a day case. The heat turns the inside of the pile into scar tissue. Over the next few weeks the pile shrinks and sticks back in place.

Nothing is cut away, so there is no open wound inside the anus. That is the main reason the first days are easier. The treated piles do swell for several days before they shrink, so the first week is not without discomfort.

Laser has limits. It shrinks a pile. It does not lift a pile that hangs out a lot. It does not remove skin tags. A large lump on the outside of the anus shrinks very little with laser.

What open surgery does

Open surgery, called haemorrhoidectomy, cuts each large pile away. It leaves small wounds that heal on their own over four to seven weeks.

The surgeon keeps bridges of normal skin between the wounds, so the anus does not become narrow. The ring of muscle that controls the bowel is left alone. Outside lumps and skin tags that belong to the pile are removed in the same sitting.

Because the swollen piles are taken out, this is the most lasting treatment for piles. The price is pain in the first week, worst with the first few bowel movements, and a slower return to work.

What banding does

Banding places a small rubber ring at the base of an inside pile in the OPD. The pile dries up and falls off within about a week.

The band sits above the line inside the anus where pain nerves begin. So most people feel only pressure or a dull ache for a day or two. No anaesthesia and no admission are needed. Many people need two or three sessions a few weeks apart.

For bleeding piles of grade 1 to 3, banding is usually the next step after diet and medicines. It is quick, and you can go home straight after.

Laser and surgery side by side

Laser wins on comfort and speed of recovery. Surgery wins on how long the result lasts. Neither is right for everyone.

Laser treatment compared with open surgery for piles
QuestionLaser (used at other centres)Open surgery
What happens to the pile?Shrunk from insideCut away
Wound inside the anus?No, only a pinhole in the skinYes, small wounds that heal
Pain in the first weekUsually lessMore, worst with bowel movements
Back to workUsually soonerOften around two weeks
Large outside lump or skin tagsNot treated wellRemoved
Grade 4 piles that stay outNot suitableSuitable
Chance the piles come backHigherLowest of all treatments
Common early problemA hard, sore clot in a leftover outside partPain, and trouble passing urine on the first day
Extra costA single-use laser fibreStandard instruments

What the careful studies found

Trials agree that laser hurts less in the first days. Over one to five years, piles came back more often after laser than after surgery.

The strongest trial was double-blind. Neither the patients nor the doctors who checked them later knew which treatment had been done. After one year, more people in the laser group needed further treatment. After five years the gap had narrowed, but surgery still did better at keeping piles away.

Larger studies that pool many trials say the same thing in another way. Laser saves roughly a week of recovery. In return, the piles are less likely to stay away. Results with laser also depend on how much energy is used in each pile, and this differs from centre to centre.

Why Dr Harsh Shah does not use laser

Dr Shah chooses the treatment by the grade of the piles. Banding and open surgery cover every grade, with long-tested results.

Other centres use laser, and for the right person it is a fair choice. Dr Shah does not use it, for three reasons.

  • Many people come to the clinic with grade 3 or 4 piles, a large outside lump or skin tags. These are the piles that laser treats least well.
  • For smaller bleeding piles, banding in the OPD already avoids an operation and a hospital stay.
  • When an operation is needed, he would rather remove the piles once than shrink them and plan for a repeat.

Laser is often sold as a treatment with no pain and no return. Neither is quite true. A clot in a leftover outside part can make the first week sore, and piles can come back.

Who might reasonably choose laser elsewhere

Laser can suit a person with grade 2 or 3 inside piles and little outside swelling, who wants a quick return and accepts a repeat chance.

The common complaint after laser is a hard, tender lump in the first two weeks. This is a small clot in an outside part of the pile that the laser could not shrink. It settles, but it can make the week sore. Swelling of the treated piles for several days is also usual.

If laser still sounds right for you, it is worth asking any surgeon these questions before you decide:

  1. What grade are my piles, and do I have an outside lump or skin tags?
  2. Will this treatment deal with the outside part too?
  3. How likely are my piles to come back after this treatment?
  4. If they come back, what would you do next?
  5. What will the first week feel like?
  6. What does the bill include, and will my insurance pay for it?

Cost and insurance

The cost depends on the treatment, the room type, the anaesthesia and the hospital stay. Laser adds the price of a single-use fibre.

Banding is done in the OPD. Many policies cover only hospital admission, so banding is often paid for directly. Open surgery needs a short admission and is usually covered under the policy, with cashless treatment where your insurer has a tie-up. Some policies have a waiting period for piles, so check yours before you plan surgery. Many insurers pay for laser only up to their usual piles rate, and the patient pays the rest.

Bleeding is checked first

Before any piles treatment, bleeding from the back passage is checked to rule out other causes higher up in the bowel.

Bright red blood on the toilet paper usually comes from piles, but not always. A colonoscopy is advised for older people, and for anyone with a change in bowel habit, weight loss, low blood count or bowel disease in the family. This check comes before choosing laser, banding or surgery.

Frequently asked questions

Is laser better than surgery for piles?

Neither is better for everyone. Laser hurts less in the first days and recovery is quicker. Surgery lasts longer and also deals with outside lumps, skin tags and grade 4 piles.

Does laser treatment for piles hurt?

It usually hurts less than surgery in the first days. The treated piles swell for a few days, and a clot in a leftover outside part can make the first week sore.

Do piles come back after laser?

They can. In careful trials, piles came back more often after laser than after open surgery, both at one year and at five years.

Does Dr Harsh Shah do laser treatment for piles?

No. He uses banding in the OPD and open surgery at Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital, Vasna, Ahmedabad, chosen by the grade of your piles. He explains laser honestly if you ask about it.

Can laser remove a large outside lump or skin tags?

Not well. Laser shrinks the inside part of a pile. A large outside lump or skin tag usually needs to be cut away.

Will insurance pay for laser piles treatment?

Policies differ. Many pay only up to their usual piles rate, and the patient pays the extra cost of the laser fibre. Ask your insurer before you decide.

Related pages

How Dr Shah treats each grade, from diet to banding to open surgery, is set out on the piles treatment page. Every problem at the back passage is covered at the piles, fissure and fistula clinic.

Where Dr Harsh Shah sees patients and operates

Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital, Vasna, Ahmedabad

Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital, Dr Jivraj Mehta Marg, Vasna, Ahmedabad 380007. Admission, open piles surgery and inpatient care.

WhatsApp +91-63555-64601 · Directions to Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital, Vasna

Comparing laser and surgery for your piles? The right choice depends on the grade, which needs an examination. Call first, or send your questions on WhatsApp before the visit. Call +91-63555-64601 Send your questions on WhatsApp

Tapping Book on WhatsApp will likely open the WhatsApp app on your phone.

Get health updates from Dr Harsh Shah on WhatsApp

Swasth Parivar: every week, practical advice on recovery, diet and warning signs. No advertising. Stop any time.

Your number is used for these updates and for the clinic to reach you. It is never sold or passed on. To stop, reply STOP on WhatsApp.

Dr. Harsh J Shah
Dr Harsh Shah, Gastro, Cancer & Laparoscopic Surgeon, Ahmedabad
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.