WhatsApp Skip to main content

Dr. Harsh J Shah

Gallstones on Your Scan: Watch Them, Plan the Keyhole Operation, or Operate During This Attack?

Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital · Vasna, Ahmedabad

Last updated: 14-Oct-2026

Gallstone and cholecystitis treatment in Ahmedabad · Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital, Vasna, Ahmedabad

Gallstones found by chance, with no pain, are usually left alone. A few special findings change that. Stones that cause true gallstone pain are removed with the whole gallbladder.

An inflamed gallbladder, called acute cholecystitis, is graded mild, moderate or severe. In a fit patient, keyhole removal in the same admission, within about a week, is the usual plan.

Not every pain with stones is gallstone pain. Bloating and burning often have another cause. The history and a few tests decide whether surgery will actually help.

Three different situations, three different plans

Stones without symptoms, stones that cause attacks of pain, and an inflamed gallbladder are three different problems. Each has its own plan and its own timing.

Dr Harsh Shah, gallbladder surgeon, Ahmedabad
Dr Harsh Shah, MS, MCh (Surgical Gastroenterology), DrNB (Surgical Gastroenterology).

Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital. Dr Harsh Shah has 18 years of experience in gallbladder, bile duct and gut surgery. Sorting true gallstone pain from indigestion, timing the operation to the attack, and reading every gallbladder report are handled by one team.

Dr Harsh Shah
MS, MCh (Surgical Gastroenterology), DrNB (Surgical Gastroenterology)
Registered with Gujarat Medical Council, Reg. No. G-38738
Gallbladder Surgeon · Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital, Vasna, Ahmedabad

Google rating 4.94 from 18 reviews at Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital, Vasna, Ahmedabad.

Which situation are you in?
SituationWhat it meansUsual plan
Stones with no symptomsFound on a scan done for something else.Watch. Surgery only for the special findings listed below.
Gallstone pain (biliary colic)Attacks of pain that come and go. The gallbladder is not infected.A planned keyhole operation, often as a day-care case.
Inflamed gallbladder (acute cholecystitis)Pain that does not settle, with tenderness and fever or raised blood markers.Hospital care. Timing of surgery is set by the grade of the attack.
A stone in the main bile ductYellow eyes, dark urine, or a widened duct on the scan.The duct is cleared first, then the gallbladder is removed.

The broader picture of gallbladder stones, the stone types and the surgical options, is on our gallbladder stone treatment page. This page is about the decisions: whether to operate, and when.

Gallstone pain, or indigestion?

Stones on an ultrasound do not explain every stomach complaint. True gallstone pain comes in attacks, lasts over half an hour, and sits in the upper belly or under the right ribs.

Telling the two apart
FeatureGallstone painIndigestion alone
How it comesIn attacks, often after a meal.Most days, on and off.
How longMore than half an hour, often hours.Short spells, or a constant mild discomfort.
WhereUpper middle belly or under the right ribs. It may go to the back or right shoulder.Vague, often with bloating.
What comes with itSweating, vomiting, needing to keep still.Belching, burning, a full feeling.
What followsA planned operation is likely to help.Another cause is looked for first. Surgery may not help.

This sorting matters. Removing the gallbladder for bloating and burning alone often leaves the symptoms in place. So when the story does not fit, other causes are checked before any operation is offered.

Stones with no symptoms: when watching is right

Silent stones are usually watched, not removed. Only a small number start causing trouble each year. Surgery is advised only when one of a few special findings is present.

Watching means no operation, no special diet and no repeated scans. You learn the signs of an attack and report them. If attacks begin, a planned operation follows.

Silent stones that are still removed
FindingWhy surgery is advised
A hard, chalky gallbladder wallThis change needs the gallbladder out.
A gallbladder polyp of 10 mm or more, or one that is growingThe polyp needs removal and examination.
Stones together with a polypThe pair is treated as a reason to remove the gallbladder.
A thickened gallbladder wallIt needs a closer look and usually removal.
Waiting for an organ transplant, or on strong immune-lowering medicinesAn attack later would be harder to treat.
A planned weight-loss bypass operationThe gallbladder is dealt with as part of the plan.

The tests, in the order they are used

An ultrasound and basic blood tests come first. Then the chance of a stone in the main bile duct is judged. That decides whether you go straight to surgery or need one more test.

  1. Ultrasound of the belly. The size and number of stones, the gallbladder wall, the width of the main bile duct, and any fluid around the gallbladder.
  2. Blood tests. Blood count, liver tests and kidney tests.
  3. Pancreas enzymes. Amylase or lipase, if the pain is unusual or will not settle.
  4. A check for a duct stone. Before every listing for surgery, using the table below.
  5. MRCP or endoscopic ultrasound. Only when the chance of a duct stone is in the middle.
Chance of a stone in the main bile duct
ChanceWhat puts you thereNext step
HighA duct stone seen on a scan. Infection of the bile duct. Deep jaundice with a widened duct.ERCP first to clear the duct, then gallbladder removal.
MiddleA widened duct. Mild jaundice. Abnormal liver tests. Age over 55. Gallstone pancreatitis.MRCP or endoscopic ultrasound. ERCP only if a stone is found.
LowNone of the above.Straight to keyhole gallbladder removal.

A stone in the main duct, or infection behind it, follows a different route. Our page on bile duct stones and cholangitis explains it. Gallstones can also inflame the pancreas. That is covered on our acute pancreatitis page.

Plain stones, or something more serious?

Most gallbladders with stones are simply that. A few scan findings raise a concern about a growth. Then the case is not listed as routine surgery. A senior surgeon plans it.

Findings that change the plan
Finding on the scanWhat follows
A thick wall, more than 4 mm, with no sign of inflammation.Not a routine listing. Further imaging and a senior surgeon’s plan.
A lump, or an irregular wall.Not a routine listing. Further imaging and a senior surgeon’s plan.
A hard, chalky wall.A joint team decision on how to operate.
A polyp of 10 mm or more, or a growing polyp.A joint team decision on how to operate.
Stones and a polyp together.A senior surgeon’s review before listing.

After every gallbladder operation, the removed gallbladder is opened and checked in theatre. It is always sent for examination under the microscope. A doctor reads every report. Occasionally an unexpected growth is found, and then the next steps are discussed within two weeks. This is why the report is never skipped.

An inflamed gallbladder: how bad is this attack?

An inflamed gallbladder is confirmed by tenderness under the right ribs, a sign of body-wide inflammation such as fever, and typical ultrasound changes. The attack is then graded.

The three grades, in plain words
GradeWhat it means
MildInflamed, but none of the moderate or severe features.
ModerateAny one of: a very high white cell count, a tender lump under the right ribs, symptoms for more than three days, or a gallbladder that is dying, has gas in its wall, or has a pus collection or leak around it.
SevereAn organ is failing. Low blood pressure needing drugs, drowsiness or confusion, poor breathing, failing kidneys, slow clotting or low platelets.

The grade is written down on the day you arrive. It is checked again every day, because an attack can change. The grade, your fitness and the state of the gallbladder together set the plan.

Grade and fitness decide the timing

For a fit patient with a mild or moderate attack, keyhole removal in the same admission is the usual plan. A drain is a bridge for those too unwell for surgery.

The plan by grade
GradeFit patient, experienced unitUnfit patient, or very hostile anatomy
MildEarly keyhole removal in the same admission.Antibiotics, then a planned operation later.
ModerateEarly keyhole removal in the same admission, by an experienced surgeon.A drain into the gallbladder through the skin, antibiotics, then surgery later.
SevereOrgan support first. Early surgery only in selected patients at an advanced centre.A gallbladder drain and organ support, then a planned operation later.

Early means within about 72 hours, and up to seven days, from when the symptoms began. Studies show early surgery shortens the total time in hospital. It does not raise the chance of changing to open surgery or of a bile duct injury.

If you arrive more than about a week after the pain began, the inflammation may have set hard. Then the attack is settled with treatment first. The operation follows at about six weeks.

The first hours in hospital

Antibiotics support the body, but they do not end the problem. In a fit patient with a mild or moderate attack, the operation in the same admission is the treatment.

  1. Nothing by mouth at first. Sips and light food return early, once you improve.
  2. Fluids through a drip. To correct dehydration from vomiting.
  3. Antibiotics through a drip. Chosen to match the usual germs in the hospital.
  4. Pain relief. An anti-inflammatory painkiller first, if the kidneys allow. Stronger medicine if needed.
  5. Anti-sickness medicine and clot prevention. Given to every patient.
  6. The grade is set, and the operation slot is planned.

A drain into the gallbladder is a bridge

A thin tube through the skin can drain an infected gallbladder. It is used only for patients truly too unwell for anaesthesia. It is followed by a planned operation at six to eight weeks.

Being older or having other illnesses does not on its own mean you need a drain instead of surgery. A large trial showed that removing the gallbladder did better than a drain in high-risk patients who were fit enough for an operation. So a drain is kept for those who genuinely cannot have anaesthesia, or a severe attack not responding to treatment.

Patients sent home with a drain are easy to lose track of. So each one goes on a tracking list with a date for the later operation. You do not have to remember it. Our team calls you.

When an operation is not needed

Many people with gallstones never need surgery. Silent stones are watched. Vague indigestion is investigated for another cause. Only the whole gallbladder, never the stones alone, is ever removed.

No operation, or not yet
SituationWhy surgery is not the answer now
Silent stones with none of the special findings.Only a small number start causing trouble each year.
Bloating, belching and burning without attacks.Removing the gallbladder may not help. Another cause is looked for.
A patient too unwell for anaesthesia during an attack.A drain and antibiotics first. Surgery later, if fitness returns.
A request to remove only the stones.Stones form again in a gallbladder left behind. The whole gallbladder is removed.

The keyhole operation and its main safety rule

The standard operation is keyhole removal of the whole gallbladder with its stones. Before any tube is clipped, the surgeon must see a clear, safe view of the anatomy.

This safe view has three parts. The fat and tissue in a small triangle near the gallbladder are cleared. The lower part of the gallbladder is lifted off the liver bed. And only two structures, one tube and one artery, are seen entering the gallbladder. Only then is anything clipped and cut.

When inflammation makes that view impossible, the surgeon does not push on. Safer choices follow. Part of the gallbladder can be left behind on purpose, the gallbladder can be freed from the top down, an X-ray of the bile ducts can be taken, or the operation can be changed to open surgery. Changing to open is a judgement for safety, not a failure.

From Dr Harsh Shah’s channel: how a difficult, swollen gallbladder is removed through keyhole surgery.

Other standards are part of every operation. Gas pressure is kept low where possible. A drain tube and a nose tube are not used routinely. Local anaesthetic is injected at the small cuts. Medicines to prevent sickness are given. How difficult the gallbladder was is recorded in the operation note.

Before the operation

You get written fasting instructions and a list of danger signs. For a planned operation, a sweet clear drink two hours before helps you recover faster.

  1. Fasting. No solid food for six hours. Clear fluids up to two hours before.
  2. A carbohydrate drink. For planned operations, a clear sweet drink two hours before surgery.
  3. Your usual medicines. Essential ones continue. A plan is made for blood thinners and diabetes medicines.
  4. A fitness check. By the anaesthetist, with your risk of clots assessed.
  5. Counselling. The operation is explained, and you take home a danger-sign sheet.

The day of surgery and going home

Most planned keyhole gallbladder operations are day-care or one-night stays. You drink at two hours, eat a light meal soon after, and go home once you meet the checks.

The first day after a planned operation
WhenWhat happens
Two hoursSips of fluid. Sitting out of bed.
Four to six hoursA light meal. Walking. Passing urine.
Same evening or next morningHome once pain is controlled on tablets, you are eating, walking and passing urine, and you have the danger-sign sheet.
At homeSimple painkillers for three to five days. No routine antibiotics after a clean mild or moderate case.

Do not go home, or come back at once, with any of these.

  1. Fever.
  2. Pain that is getting worse instead of better.
  3. Green or bile-coloured fluid from a wound, or bile-coloured vomiting.
  4. Yellow eyes or skin.

What patients say

★★★★★

“Dr. Harsh performed my wife’s gallbladder surgery and has been a thorough professional. He truly assuaged our concerns and treated us with great care. I have never met a surgeon who is consistently upbeat, and that makes a real difference to families whose loved ones are undergoing a surgical procedure. — Gaurav Roy, Google review”

★★★★★

“Dr. Harsh Shah performed gallbladder surgery for my father, and our experience was excellent. He is very humble and highly knowledgeable. He patiently answered all our queries and took great care in explaining every detail. He was always supportive and addressed each of my father’s concerns with patience and clarity, which gave us a lot of confidence and comfort throughout the treatment. We are truly grateful for his care and would highly recommend him. — Sunny Shah, Google review”

★★★★★

“I am very thankful to Dr. Harsh Shah for treating me for gallstone disease and performing my laparoscopic cholecystectomy. The entire treatment and surgery were handled very professionally. Dr. Harsh Shah explained everything clearly and made me feel comfortable throughout the process. My recovery has been very good, and I am extremely satisfied with the care I received. Highly recommended for laparoscopic and gastrointestinal surgery. — Akshaya Shaw, Google review”

These reviews are from Dr Harsh Shah’s two Google listings, quoted exactly as written. Each describes his care for gallbladder surgery.

A patient describes keyhole gallbladder surgery at the age of 73, shared with consent.

The risks, named in words

Keyhole gallbladder surgery is a common operation, but it carries real risks. They are explained in person before consent, with the figures that apply to you. Risk is higher during an acute attack.

General risks: bleeding that may need a transfusion, wound infection, clots in the legs or lungs, a heart problem around the operation, and anaesthetic problems.

Risks of this operation: an injury to the main bile duct, which is uncommon but the most important risk, and is discussed in detail. A bile leak. A stone left in the duct that needs an ERCP. Changing to open surgery. An injury to the bowel or a blood vessel when the first cut is made. A fluid collection under the liver. Part of the gallbladder left behind on purpose when the anatomy is unsafe. Death is rare.

In the long run: usually nothing. Some people have loose motions for a while. Report yellow eyes or fever at any time. Risks are higher with age over 65, other serious illness, a heavy build, earlier upper belly surgery, or an acute attack. Dr Harsh Shah goes through each of these in person before consent.

Special situations that need a senior surgeon the same day

Some gallstone problems are not routine. Pregnancy, liver cirrhosis, a severe attack, a duct infection or an unusual scan finding all bring a senior surgeon in on the same day.

Same-day senior review
SituationWhy
Acute attack during pregnancyThe timing and method need extra care for mother and baby.
Liver cirrhosis or high pressure in the liver veinsBleeding risk is higher, and the plan changes.
Severe attack with an organ failingOrgan support and drainage come first.
Fever with yellow eyes and painInfection of the bile duct. Urgent drainage, not a gallbladder listing.
A stone pressing on the main bile duct from outsideThe anatomy is distorted, and the operation is planned differently.
A gallstone blocking the bowelAn emergency operation on the bowel.
Any finding that suggests a growthNot a routine operation, as described above.

Follow-up after the operation

A phone call on the first day, then a wound check and the gallbladder report at seven to ten days. After a simple operation, no special diet and no routine scans are needed.

After gallbladder removal
WhenWhat happens
Day one, for day-care casesA phone call from our coordinator.
Seven to ten daysWound check. The microscope report is read by a doctor and explained to you.
DietNo long-term restriction.
ScansNone routinely after a simple operation.
Patients with a gallbladder drainKept on a tracking list for the planned operation at six to eight weeks.
Weeks later, pain with abnormal liver testsAn MRCP looks for a stone left in the duct. ERCP removes it.

Your path, from first visit to follow-up

  1. Book your consultation. Bring the ultrasound report, blood reports, any discharge papers and a list of medicines. A severe attack with fever goes to the emergency department at Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital, Vasna, Ahmedabad.
  2. Sort the problem. Silent stones, gallstone pain, an inflamed gallbladder, or a duct stone.
  3. Check the duct. The chance of a duct stone decides if one more test is needed.
  4. Time the operation. Planned day-care, same admission for an attack, or later after a drain.
  5. Follow-up. Wound check and the gallbladder report at seven to ten days.

Cost, insurance and admission

A planned keyhole operation is usually a day-care or one-night stay. An acute attack needs a longer admission. The estimate depends on the grade, the operation and the stay.

The estimate also depends on any MRCP or ERCP, a drain, and intensive care for a severe attack. Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital, Vasna, Ahmedabad, works with the major insurers and cashless schemes. The office handles pre-authorisation, including for emergency admissions with an attack. Bring: ultrasound and blood reports, discharge papers, a list of medicines, the insurance card and identification. You can also call +91-63555-64601 to ask what to bring.

Cashless at Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital

Gallbladder removal, laparoscopic or open, is on Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital’s PPN package list, so it is cashless if your policy is with one of the four public-sector insurers: New India Assurance, Oriental Insurance, United India Insurance or National Insurance (GIPSA PPN). The hospital’s TPA desk handles the pre-authorisation. Bring your policy card, photo ID and reports. If you are insured elsewhere, insurance is still accepted and the desk applies for cashless approval under your policy.

Frequently asked questions

My stones cause no pain. Should I have them removed?

Usually not. Silent stones are watched. Surgery is advised only for special findings, such as a chalky wall, a polyp of 10 mm or more, or a planned transplant.

Can only the stones be removed and the gallbladder kept?

No. Stones form again in a gallbladder left behind. The standard operation removes the whole gallbladder with its stones.

I had an attack. Should I wait for it to settle before surgery?

Not if you are fit and the attack is mild or moderate. Keyhole removal in the same admission, within about a week of the pain starting, is the usual plan.

I arrived a week after the pain started. What now?

The attack is usually settled with treatment first. The operation then follows at about six weeks, once the inflammation has calmed.

Why was I given a drain instead of an operation?

A drain is for patients too unwell for anaesthesia, or a severe attack not settling. It is a bridge. A planned operation follows at six to eight weeks.

Will I need a special diet after the gallbladder is removed?

No long-term diet restriction is needed. Some people have loose motions for a while. Report yellow eyes or fever at any time.

Why is my gallbladder sent to the laboratory?

Every removed gallbladder is examined under the microscope. Occasionally an unexpected finding appears. A doctor reads every report and explains it at the follow-up visit.

Is gallbladder removal cashless at Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital?

Yes, for policyholders of New India Assurance, Oriental Insurance, United India Insurance and National Insurance, because it is a PPN package operation. The hospital's TPA desk handles pre-authorisation. With other insurers, the desk applies for cashless approval under your policy.

Where Dr Harsh Shah sees and operates

Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital, Vasna, Ahmedabad
Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital, Dr Jivraj Mehta Marg, Vasna, Ahmedabad 380007.
Google: Dr Harsh Shah · 4.94 from 18 reviews
Directions to Dr. Jivraj Mehta Hospital, Vasna · WhatsApp +91-63555-64601

Patients come to Ahmedabad from across Gujarat, including Gandhinagar, Mehsana, Nadiad, Anand, Rajkot and Kutch, and from southern Rajasthan.

Told you have gallstones, or had a bad attack of upper belly pain? Ultrasound and blood reports, and any discharge papers, can be sent ahead, so the consultation starts with them already read. Treatment is decided at the consultation, after examination. Pain with fever, yellow eyes or vomiting that will not stop needs the nearest emergency department today. Call +91-63555-64601 · Bring the reports to the visit

Rate this page

Get health updates from Dr Harsh Shah on WhatsApp

Swasth Parivar: every week, practical advice on recovery, diet and warning signs. No advertising. Stop any time.

Your number is used for these updates and for the clinic to reach you. It is never sold or passed on. To stop, reply STOP on WhatsApp.

Dr. Harsh J Shah
Dr Harsh Shah, Gastro, Cancer & Laparoscopic Surgeon, Ahmedabad
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.